Partitioning soil carbon responses to warming: Model-derived guidance for data interpretation

Parallel incubation at different temperatures combined with 13CO2 efflux has been used to distinguish the temperature sensitivity of labile soil carbon (young soil carbon derived from newly-introduced vegetation) from that of resistant soil carbon (old, native vegetation-derived soil carbon). But we believe that this approach to assessing relative temperature sensitivities is confounded by differential rates of depletion of labile and resistant soil carbon at different temperatures. Here we employ a simple decomposition model to demonstrate potential pitfalls in interpreting 13CO2 efflux data that inevitably, and potentially erroneously, lead to the conclusion that decomposition of resistant soil carbon pools is more temperature sensitive than labile pools. We conclude by offering a new approach for interpreting these data that eliminates this potential bias.