Validation of in sacco method: influence of sampling site, nylon bag or rumen contents, on fibrolytic activity of solid-associated microorganisms

Three ruminally cannulated cows, fed twice daily with a 70:30 forage:concentrate diet, were used to investigate the differences in fibrolytic activity of solid-associated microorganisms between nylon bags and rumen contents. Two different grass hays (regrowth and late harvested) were incubated in ruminal nylon bags. After 2 h or 23 h incubation time, pH was measured in bags and rumen contents, and enzymes of solid-associated microorganisms were extracted from bag residues and surrounding digesta by grinding, freezing, defrosting and sonication. Xylanase, avicelase, β-D-xylosidase and β-D-glucosidase activities were measured. Activities were lower in bag residues than in rumen digesta, and differences were greater after 2 h than after 23 h incubation time. Causes of these differences are discussed. For each incubation time and each enzyme, the differences in solid-associated microorganisms activities between rumen and bags contents were independent of the quality of hay in the bag. Thus the lower fibrolytic activity inside the bags may account for an underestimation of in vivo ruminal fiber degradation by the in sacco method, but this underestimation may be similar whatever the nature and content of forage cell walls.