Geometrical mechanism of inverse grading in grain-flow deposits: An experimental revelation

The grain-flow has so far been defined with reference to the distinctive sediment-support mechanism, the dispersive pressure. The role of sediment-support mechanism, however, is required in a multiphase flow to prevent the gravitational settling of the particles through the driving medium during the flow. In a single-phase flow of non-cohesive grains no such secondary mechanism is required to counteract the gravitational pull, the driving force of the flow. So the definition of grain-flow needs a critical revision. This, in turn, involves proper understanding of the grain-flow mechanism, so that the relation between the process and the product can be properly established. The most distinctive feature often demonstrated by a grain-flow deposit is the particle size segregation, which leads to the development of inverse grading. The available explanations for this phenomenon find theoretical constraints. In the present study an attempt was made to understand the mechanism of single-phase non-cohesive granular flow of different flow regime and the particle segregation pattern in the resultant deposit through laboratory simulation. The experimental observations revealed that no sustained granular flow sets in on a slope deviating much from the limiting value of the angle of repose of the granular material. A persistent simple shear flow develops on slopes of this critical value. Each of the grains rolls in response to simple shearing. If the shear stress attains a critical value, theoretically the larger grains can even climb up the adjacent smaller ones towards the down-slope direction. In reality, however, high angle climb is not very common. The larger grains preferably roll over the smaller grains when the common tangent becomes almost horizontal or makes a very low angle with the direction of flow, and by this process gradually reaches the upper surface of the flow causing the development of inverse grading. The upper surface of the resultant deposit remains parallel to the sloping substratum. These properties readily distinguish this variety of granular flow from the other natural flows, and the flow may thus be assigned the distinct status of grain-flow.