Investigation of a Boeing 747 wing main landing gear trunnion failure

A loud noise was heard from the vicinity of the port wing landing gear during pushback of a Boeing 747-300 from the terminal at Sydney (Australia) airport. Inspection showed that one of the wing landing gear trunnion fork assemblies had failed. Detailed investigation revealed that the trunnion had failed by fatigue cracking. Deep machining grooves were found at the root of an internal radius that had not been shot-peened as required, and a chemical surface process during manufacture had resulted in shallow intergranular attack at the bottom of these grooves. It is probable that the critical cracking started from some of these grooves. In addition, the wall thickness at the failure location was significantly less than the minimum required in the drawings. the deep machining grooves, the lack of peening and the intergranular attack were all consequences of manufacturing, the fatigue cracking probably started shortly after the component entered service. This implies that fatigue cracking was present during all the trunnion overhauls, but was not detected by non-destructive inspections during the overhauls. Quantitative fractography was used to produce a crack growth curve based on fracture surface markings thought to represent the overhaul timings. The crack growth curve suggested that the fatigue cracking was large enough to be detected by inspection during the last overhaul, if not the one before. However, it was probably not easy to detect the cracking. This investigation therefore highlights the difficulties that can be encountered when inspection is the last (or only) line of defence against failure owing to unexpected manufacturing deficiencies.