Title of article :
Kāshif al-Ghiṭā's Methodology in Criticism of New Testament (Christianity)
Author/Authors :
Fattahizade, Fathiyeh Faculty of Theology - Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran , Zakeri, Marzieh Faculty of Theology - Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract :
This paper explores the method Allāmeh Muhammad Husayn Kāshif al-Ghiṭā, a
famous Muslim theorist of the 18-19th centuries, employed in his critique of
Christianity. Although, his method for looking into the Bible is similar to that of
Christian and Jewish scholars, his assumptions and results are different. Based on
his viewpoints on the Bible, he believes in impeccable revelations. He examined
superstructure, namely accuracy of attribution of books and pamphlets to their
authors as well as personality and credibility of Jesus Christ’s disciples and
apostles. Lack of credibility of the twelve original disciples of Jesus Christ and
unreliability of the Gospels are proved. Moreover, he has carefully examined the
content as infrastructure of the New Testament. As such, incongruities can be
observed between the New Testament and the Old Testament. There are
contradictions in the Bible itself. He prefers to apply argumentative tactic for
general readers. In addition, his application of comparative step in his critique is
considerable. This paper studies Kāshif al-Ghiṭā's approach to review the Bible in
order to figure out Muslim scholars' viewpoints on the Christianity.
Farsi abstract :
مقالۀ حاضر روشمندي علامه محمدحسين كاشف الغطاء انديشمند مسلمان قرن 18 - 19 را در نقد مسيحيت بررسي
مي كند. اگرچه كاشف الغطاء همچون انديشمندان مسيحي و يهودي به بازبيني محتواي انجيل مي پردازد، پيش فرضها
و نتايج برآمده از نقد او متفاوت است. كاشف الغطاء انجيل را همچون قرآن كتاب آسماني و وحياني مي داند. او چنانكه به
روساخت عهد جديد يعني كتاب شناسي، نسخه شناسي، سندشناسي، حجيت و تاريخ اناجيل پرداخته، ژرف ساخت آن را كه
بررسي محتوايي عهد جديد است، مورد مداقه قرار داده است. در نقد او عدم اعتبار اناجيل اثبات مي شود و صحت مقام
حواريون مورد ترديد قرار مي گيرد. از نگاه او نه تنها ميان عهد قديم و جديد تناقضه اي پديده مي شود كه حتي در محتواي
خود عهد جديد نيز تفاوتها و تناقض هايي به چشم مي خورد. روش برهاني و تطبيقي مباني نقد او را مستحكم كرده است.
اين پژوهش با هدف معرفي چهره هاي نقد كتاب مقدس در ميان انديشمندان مسلمان نگاشته شده است
Keywords :
The Bible , The New Testament , Christianity , Kāshif al-Ghiṭā , Methodology
Journal title :
Astroparticle Physics