Title of article :
The Authors’ Reply
Author/Authors :
Farajzadeh, Mohammad Emergency Ward - Imam Khomeini Hospital of Saghez - Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences - Sanandaj, Iran , Ghanei Gheshlagh, Reza Clinical Care Research Center - Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences - Sanandaj, Iran , Sayehmiri, Kourosh Department of Biostatistics - Psychosocial Injury Research Center - Ilam University of Medical Sciences - Ilam, Iran
Abstract :
I would like to thank for reviewing and criticizing the study entitle: “Quality of life in Iranian senior
citizen: A systematic review and meta-analysis. With regard to the lack of using the Web of Science
database and the lack of inclusion of some studies”, it is necessary to mention the following points:
The growth and dispersion of studies have made it difficult to find up-to-date and relevant
information.1 As no database covers all the health topics, it is recommended that multiple databases
should be used for search.2 As the authors of “letter to editor” mentioned, the Web of Science
database has not been used. This issue will be considered in future studies.
Another point mentioned was neglecting the mean score for all the eight SF-36 domains. It
should be noted that in reviewing the inclusion and exclusion criteria of the studies, the reviewers’
mentality may inevitably play a role and cause inclusion and exclusion criteria to be interpreted
differently. The systematic review question determines which types of studies should be analyzed,3
and the purpose of this study was to estimate the overall score of the quality of life in the Iranian
elderly (not its various dimensions). Therefore, the mean score for all the eight SF-36 domains
has not been considered in the results.
Regarding missing three articles in the review,4-6 considering the similarities between the
overall mean score of the quality of life in these three studies and the overall score estimation in
our study, adding these three studies makes no significant changes in the mean score. Furthermore,
as in some studies in which the mean score of quality of life’s dimensions was not reported, the
study of quality of life’s dimensions was not one of the objectives of this study
Keywords :
The Authors’ Reply , Letter to Editor , Quality of life in Iranian senior citizen , A systematic review and meta-analysis , lack of inclusion of some studies , lack of using the Web of Science database
Journal title :
International Journal of Community Based Nursing and Midwifery