Title of article :
Comparison the Emergency Severity Index and Manchester Triage System in Trauma Patients
Author/Authors :
Zakeri, Hossein Department of Emergency Medicine - Mashhad University of Medical Sciences - Mashhad, Iran , Afshari Saleh, Lahya Department of Occupational Medicine - Division of Sleep Medicine - Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences Research Center - Mashhad University of Medical Sciences - Mashhad, Iran , Niroumand, Shabnam Department of Community Medicine - Faculty of Medicine - Mashhad University of Medical Sciences - Mashhad, Iran , Ziadi-Lotfabadi, Maryam Department of Emergency Medicine - Mashhad University of Medical Sciences - Mashhad, Iran
Abstract :
To compare the emergency severity index (ESI) and Manchester triage system (MTS) in trauma
patients.
Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted by census method in Hasheminejad hospital during 2019.
Patients referred to a trauma center triaged by five trained triage nurses based on ESI and MTS. Outcomes
were considered as length of stay at the emergency department, admission to the other sectors and discharge or
leave the hospital. Information from the triage form, nursing registry office and hospital registry system were
extracted and analyzed by SPSS software.
Results: Totally 447 and 468 patients triaged with the ESI and MTS were included, respectively. Seventy
percent of patients triaged with ESI and 34% with MTS were placed in level 3 or the yellow group (equivalent
group 3 triage). The hospitalization rate is approximately equal at each triage level in the both systems. The
mortality rate in both groups was 0%. Mean length of stay was significantly lower in the MTS group compared
to ESI in the emergency department (p<0.05).
Conclusion: Using of ESI triage in the trauma center causes to arrive more patients to the emergency department
instead of the fast track and leads to waste the time and energy of staff’. However, further studies are needed
to prove this result.
Keywords :
Emergency medicine , Patient outcome , Triage , Trauma Severity Indexes
Journal title :
Bulletin of Emergency and Trauma