Relative competitiveness of nine early-successional boreal forest species associated with planted jack pine and black spruce seedlings

Differences in yield-density models derived from an additive experimental design were used to compare the relative competitiveness of nine early-successional boreal forest plants (aster, grass, fireweed, fern, raspberry, willow, alder, birch, and aspen) on jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) and black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill.) BSP). A randomized complete block split-split-plot design with three replications blocked on soil type was used. Initial density gradients were 0-4 plants/m2 for woody and 0-8 plants/m2 for herbaceous species. An a priori analytical approach that compared a full model (using linear regression analysis of 4th-year stem diameter of conifers under increasing cover and height of competitors) to various reduced models was used to assess competition. Increasing cover and (or) height of all competitors (except fern) significantly (P < 0.05) decreased conifer stem diameter. The final regression model (based on visual estimates of cover and differences in initial conifer size) accounted for 89% of the variation in stem diameter. During the years studied, both conifers responded similarly to competition, and herbaceous species were on average 28.9% more competitive than woody species. Under different growing conditions (e.g., a natural forest) the relative competitiveness of herbaceous and woody species may vary from these results.