Meniscal repair by fibrocartilage in the dog: characterization of the repair tissue and the role of vascularity

Lesions in the avascular part of 20 canine menisci were repaired by implantation of a porous polyurethane. Seven menisci were not repaired and served as controls. The repair tissue was characterized by biochemical and immunological analysis. The role of vascularity in healing was studied by perfusion of menisci with Indian ink. Histologically, repair tissue inside the implants initially consisted of fibrous tissue containing type I collagen. After 2 months, fibrocartilaginous tissue developed inside the implants, whereas control defects only showed repair with fibrous tissue. Both type I and type II collagen, the two major collagen types of normal meniscal fibrocartilage, could be detected in this newly formed fibrocartilage. The implant guided vascular tissue from the periphery towards the lesion resulting in healing of the tear. After fibrocartilage had formed, vascularity decreased and was completely absent in mature fibrocartilage. Control defects remained filled with vascular connective tissue. Two-thirds of the longitudinal lesions were found to be healed partially or completely. It is concluded that implantation of a porous polymer does enhance vascularity sufficiently to result in healing of meniscal lesions extending into the avascular part. Healing takes place by repair tissue strongly resembling normal meniscal fibrocartilage.