Clinicopathological forms and prognostic index in Budd-Chiari syndrome

Background: A recent study in patients with Budd-Chiari syndrome showed the value of a prognostic index including age, Pugh score, ascites and serum creatinine. Surgical portosystemic shunt did not appear to improve survival. Aims: To validate these findings in an independent sample; to evaluate a classification into three forms according to the presence of features of acute injury, chronic lesions, or both of them (types I, II or III, respectively); and to assess whether taking into account this classification would alter our previous conclusions. Methods: Multivariate Cox model survival analysis, first on 69 new patients; second, on these 69 and 54 previous patients, all diagnosed since 1985. Results: Previous prognostic index had a significant prognostic value (P<0.0001) which was further improved by taking into account type III form (P<0.001). Type III form was associated with the poorest outcome. No significant impact of surgical shunting on survival was disclosed. Conclusions: The prognosis of Budd-Chiari syndrome can be based on age, Pugh score, ascites, serum creatinine and the presence of features indicating acute injury superimposed on chronic lesions (type III form). The idea that surgical shunting has no significant impact on survival is reinforced by these findings.