Abstract :
I respond to the foregoing essays and take up an ambivalent defense ofHirshman’s argument. While agreeing with various points the contributors make, I highlight the fact that women’s choices are still made under conditions of oppression that shape not only the options women have, but the desires themselves that shape their choices. Recognizing oppression as a social phenomenon allows feminists to accept a wider range of individual choices than we might think acceptable under the feminist umbrella, but it also requires a distinction between making a feminist choice and offering feminist support for choice.
