Effects of stilbene optical brighteners on the insecticidal activity of Bacillus thuringiensis and a single nucleopolyhedrovirus on Helicoverpa armigera

The incorporation of certain stilbene optical brighteners into virus-based formulations has been demonstrated to increase viral pathogenicity (as indicated by reduced LD/LC50 values) but their effect on Bacillus thuringiensis activity has been scarcely investigated. We determined the effect of nine optical brighteners on the insecticidal activity of B. thuringiensis ser. kurstaki HD-1 strain (Bt HD-1) on Helicoverpa armigera and also compared the effect of two optical brighteners on the insecticidal activity of Bt HD-1 and occlusion bodies (OBs) of a Spanish isolate of H. armigera single nucleocapsid nucleopolyhedrovirus (HearNPV-SP1). Blankophor CLE, Blankophor DRS, Blankophor ER, and Leucophor SAC significantly increased the pathogenicity of Bt HD-1. In contrast, Tinopal UNPA-GX, Tinopal CBS, Blankophor BA, Leucophor AP, and Leucophor UO had an adverse or no effect on its insecticidal activity. Mixtures of HearNPV-SP1 OBs with Tinopal UNPA-GX or Leucophor UO resulted in 31.4- and 11.4-fold increases in pathogenicity, respectively, at 1%, and 11.4- and 6.3-fold increases in pathogenicity, respectively, at 0.1%, compared to the OBs alone. However, none of these brighteners increased Bt HD-1 activity. These results appear consistent with the hypothesis that the enhancement of HearNPV-SP1 pathogenicity and the null or antagonistic effects observed in Bt HD-1 against H. armigera were due to optical brightener-mediated degradation of the peritrophic membrane, but additional systematic studies involving a broad range of brighteners and electron microscope observations are required to confirm this premise.