Turbulence, watermass stratification and harmful algal blooms: an alternative view and frontal zones as “pelagic seed banks”

Watermass stratification has been considered the essential physical condition that dinoflagellates require to bloom because of their relative inability, unlike diatoms, to tolerate the elevated shear-stress associated with water-column mixing, turbulence and high velocity, coastal currents. The swimming speeds of 71 flagellate taxa, with a focus on dinoflagellates, are compared to the turbulence fields and vertical velocities that develop during representative wind conditions, upwelling and at frontal zones. The results suggest that the classical stratification–dinoflagellate bloom paradigm needs revision. Tolerance of turbulence, growth within well-mixed watermasses and survival and dispersal while entrained within current systems are well developed capacities among dinoflagellates. Their secretion of mucous, often copious during blooms, is suggested to be an environmental engineering strategy to dampen turbulence. Biophysical tolerance of turbulence by dinoflagellates is often accompanied by high swimming speeds. Motility speeds of many species exceed in situ vertical current velocities; this also allows diel migrational patterns and other motility-based behavior to persist. Species belonging to “mixing-drift” life-form assemblages can increase their swimming speeds through chain formation, which helps to compensate for the increased turbulence and vertical water-column velocities of their habitats. The ability of dinoflagellate species to tolerate the vertical velocities of offshore, frontal zones, where abundant populations often develop, suggests that fronts may serve as “pelagic seed banks”, occurring as pelagic analogues of nearshore seed beds, from which seed stock is dispersed. The different ecologies associated with the hypothesized, “pelagic seed banks” of vegetative cells and the “seed beds” of resting stage cells deposited onto sediments are discussed. There is a contradiction in the stratification–HAB paradigm: the quiescent conditions of a stratified watermass, with its characteristic nutrient-poor conditions are expected to promote stasis of the population, rather than growth and blooms. The analyses suggest that dinoflagellate blooms do not preponderate in stratified watermasses because the bloom species are biophysically intolerant of the higher velocities and turbulence of more mixed watermasses. The watermass stratification that often accompanies flagellate blooms is probably a secondary, parallel event and less essential than some other factor(s) in triggering the observed bloom.