Ozone indices based on simple meteorological parameters: potentials and limitations of regression and neural network models

This study tested the usefulness of extremely simple meteorological models for the prediction of ozone indices. The models were developed with the input parameters of daily maximum temperature and sunshine duration and are based on a data collection period of three years. For a rural environment in eastern Austria, the meteorological and ozone data of three summer periods have been used to develop functions to describe three ozone exposure indices (daily maximum, 7 h mean 9.00–16.00 h, accumulated ozone dose AOT40). Data sets for other years or stations not included in the development of the models were used as test data to validate the performance of the models. Generally, optimized regression models performed better than simplest linear models, especially in the case of AOT40. For the description of the summer period from May to September, the mean absolute daily differences between observed and calculated indices were 8±6 ppb for the maximum half hour mean value, 6±5 ppb for the 7 h mean and 41±40 ppb h for the AOT40. When the parameters were further optimized to describe individual months separately, the mean absolute residuals decreased by 10%. Neural network models did not always perform better than the regression models. This is attributed to the low number of inputs in this comparison and to the simple architecture of these models (2-2-1). Further factorial analyses of those days when the residuals were higher than the mean plus one standard deviation should reveal possible reasons why the models did not perform well on certain days. It was observed that overestimations by the models mainly occurred on days with partly overcast, hazy or very windy conditions. Underestimations more frequently occurred on weekdays than on weekends. It is suggested that the application of this kind of meteorological model will be more successful in topographically homogeneous regions and in rural environments with relatively constant rates of emission and long-range transport of ozone precursors. Under conditions too demanding for advanced physico/chemical models, the presented models may offer useful alternatives to derive ecologically relevant ozone indices directly from meteorological parameters