عنوان به زبان ديگر :
Can radiographic plain film be used to determine the depth of the tumour bed in the absence of surgical clips for breast boost planning?
پديد آورندگان :
Chitapanarux I نويسنده , Muttarak M نويسنده , Na-Chiangmai W نويسنده , Kamnerdsupaphon P نويسنده , Tharavichitkul E نويسنده , Sukthomya V نويسنده , Lorvidhaya V نويسنده , Watcharawipha A نويسنده , Somwangprasert A نويسنده
چكيده لاتين :
Purpose: A number of studies have demonstrated the importance of using surgical clips to define the tumour bed in
breast boost radiotherapy. In the absence of such clips, other techniques suggested to improve boost location have
included CT and ultrasound (US). Determination of the depth of the tumour bed is important in the selection of electron
energy. This study was conducted to prospectively compare the depth of the lumpectomy cavity as defined by ultrasound
to radiographic plain film evaluation of the anterior border of the pectoralis muscle.
Materials and Methods: Forty-one breast-cancer patients treated at the Division of Therapeutic Radiology and
Oncology, Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Chiang Mai University between December 2004 and
December 2006 were prospectively identified as having no surgical clips within the lumpectomy cavity. All patients
underwent both US evaluation of the depth of tumour bed (D1) and radiographic evaluation of the depth of the anterior
border of the pectoralis muscle (D2). These depth dimensions (D1 and D2) were compared using a paired t-test. The
correlation of both methods was analyzed by Pearson correlation test.
Results: Depth dimensions by US were shorter than the radiographic film method in 85% of patients. The absolute
mean difference of the depth (radiographic films minus US) was 0.129 cm. A paired t-test demonstrated that the
difference between these two methods to be not statistically significant (p= 0.27). The absolute difference of depth
between the two methods ranged from 0 to 0.5 cm. A significant correlation was found between US and radiographic
film measurements (p<0.01).
Conclusion: Plane radiographic film evaluation of the anterior border of the pectoralis muscle can be used to define
the depth of the tumour bed in patients who have no surgical clips. However, the plane radiographic film method
determines only the depth, not the transverse and longitudinal dimensions of the tumour bed. Additional information
from US is needed to delineate the target volume for the
tumour bed boost. In the absence of surgical clips, the
authors recommend integration of both methods in breast
boost planning process.