Comments on "Analysis and Synthesis of Nonlinear Reciprocal Networks containing two Element Types and Transformers

The above paper[1] proposes basic definitions and conventi which are not appropriate for nonlinear networks in general, although I may be appropriate for the class of networks to which the paper addressed. Since the paper[1] does not make this distinction clear, this l is written in the hope that these concepts will be subjected to crit scrutiny before adoption elsewhere in the literature. The new res appearing in the paper[1] are not affected by this discussion of fundamen