An Evaluation of Exponential and Weibull Test Plans

MIL-STD-781B gives sampling plans (sequential and fixed length) for reliability tests under the assumption of a constant failure rate. Using Monte Carlo techniques, the authors compare s-expected time to a decision and producer and consumer risks for some of these plans. It is shown that plans which assume an exponential distribution are not robust to departures from that assumption. A simple modification of these plans for use when life has a Weibull distribution with known shape parameter not equal to one, and an adaptive test procedure for use when life has a Weibull distribution with unknown shape parameter are proposed. The modified plans for a Weibull distribution with known shape parameter have the same designated producer and consumer risks, but different s-expected time to a decision than the corresponding exponential plans. Using Monte Carlo techniques, the authors determine s-expected time to a decision and producer and consumer risks for various forms of the adaptive procedure.