Title :
How simulation languages should report results: A modest proposal
Author :
Wieland, Jamie R. ; Nelson, Barry L.
Author_Institution :
Dept. of Manage. & Quantitative Methods, Illinois State Univ., Normal, IL, USA
Abstract :
The focus of simulation software environments is on developing simulation models; much less consideration is placed on reporting results. However, the quality of the simulation model is irrelevant if the results are not interpreted correctly. The manner in which results are reported, along with a lack of standardized guidelines for reports, could contribute to the misinterpretation of results. We propose a hierarchical report structure where each reporting level provides additional detail about the simulated performance. Our approach utilizes two recent developments in output analysis: a procedure for omitting statistically meaningless digits in point estimates, and a graphical display called a MORE Plot, which conveys operational risk and statistical error in an intuitive manner on a single graph. Our motivation for developing this approach is to prevent or reduce misinterpretation of simulation results and to provide a foundation for standardized guidelines for reporting.
Keywords :
error statistics; simulation languages; software engineering; MORE Plot; graphical display; operational risk; simulation languages; simulation model quality; simulation models development; simulation software environments; statistical error; Analytical models; Displays; Engineering management; Environmental management; Guidelines; Industrial engineering; Proposals; Software development management; Stochastic systems; System performance;
Conference_Titel :
Simulation Conference (WSC), Proceedings of the 2009 Winter
Conference_Location :
Austin, TX
Print_ISBN :
978-1-4244-5770-0
DOI :
10.1109/WSC.2009.5429684