DocumentCode
1900303
Title
Simple disambiguation of Orthogonal Projection in Kalman´s filter derivation
Author
Bell, J.W.
Author_Institution
3156 Swiss Dr. Santa Clara, UT 84765, USA
fYear
2012
fDate
22-25 Oct. 2012
Firstpage
1
Lastpage
6
Abstract
In his section “Orthogonal Projections”, Kalman purports to derive his filter by orthogonally projecting a solution x(τ) onto noisy measurement data y(t) = x(t) + n(t); effectively assuming x̂ = Σai yi , minimizing E[(xi − ai yi )2], and determining ai . Conversely, under his later rubric “Solution of the Wiener Problem” he instead does the reverse by projecting data onto a prescribed solution in the form of his state equation. This is virtually equivalent to projecting data onto a polynomial; assuming x̂ = Σbj τj, minimizing E[(yi − Σbj ti j)2], and determining bj . Exceptionally subtle and cryptic, but enormously consequential; projecting a solution onto data - as Kalman purports, but fails, to do - offers superior position as well as derivative accuracy through minimization of the true MSE - comprising both variance and bias. As Kalman does, projecting data onto a prescribed solution (e.g., a state equation or polynomial) minimizes only the curve fitting variance in the constrained special case of merely producing an “average curve” (an “average state equation” in Kalman´s filter) - yielding sub-optimal accuracy. Moreover, a very disturbing consequence of Kalman´s misapplication of orthogonal projection is that the simple analysis herein strongly suggests that Kalman´s Filter is truly optimum only in the absence of the specific additive statistical measurement noise it is explicitly designed to filter out.
Keywords
Estimation; Filter; Kalman; Orthogonality; Tracking;
fLanguage
English
Publisher
iet
Conference_Titel
Radar Systems (Radar 2012), IET International Conference on
Conference_Location
Glasgow, UK
Electronic_ISBN
978-1-84919-676
Type
conf
DOI
10.1049/cp.2012.1742
Filename
6494898
Link To Document