Can We Trust Online Physician Ratings? Evidence from Cardiac Surgeons in Florida

Despite heated debate about the pros and cons of online physician ratings, very little systematic work examines the correlation between physicians´ online ratings and their actual medical performance. Using patients´ ratings of physicians at Rate MDs.com and the Florida Hospital Discharge data, we investigate whether online ratings reflect physicians´ medical performance by means of a two-stage model that takes into account patients´ ratings-based selection of cardiac surgeons. Estimation results show that five-star surgeons are associated with significantly lower mortality rates and are more likely to be selected by sicker patients compared with lower-rated surgeons. In contrast, not accounting for patients´ rating-based selection leads to the opposite outcome: patients treated by five-star surgeons had higher mortality rates than patients treated by surgeons rated below five stars. Our findings suggest that we can trust online physician ratings, at least of cardiac surgeons.