Scalable Signal Selection for Post-Silicon Debug

As modern integrated circuits increase in size and complexity, more and more verification effort is necessary to ensure their error-free operation. This has motivated designers to apply post-silicon debugging techniques to their designs, such as by embedding trace instrumentation within. However, a key drawback to this approach is that only a small subset of a chip´s internal signals can be traced, but selecting the most effective signals to observe must be determined before fabrication and before the nature of any errors is known. This paper explores the tradeoff between the scalability of automated signal selection algorithms, and the amount of circuit observability that they offer. Three selection methods are presented: a technique that optimizes for observability directly; a method based on the graph-centrality of the circuit´s connectivity; and a hybrid technique that combines both algorithms through exploiting the circuit hierarchy. To quantify the observability of each technique, we define the debug difficulty metric to measure how accurately the traced data can be used to resolve a circuit´s state behavior. Although we find that the graph-based method offers the least observability of the three algorithms, it was the only method that could be applied to our largest benchmark of over 50 000 flip-flops, computing a selection in less than 90 s. Last, we present a novel application that can only be enabled by these scalable algorithms-speculative debug insertion for field-programmable gate arrays.