Title :
The incommensurability of ´faster, better, cheaper´: NASA´s rhetorical bind
Author :
Constantinides, Helen
Author_Institution :
Dept. of Rhetoric & Sci. & Tech. Commun., Minnesota Univ., Duluth, MN, USA
Abstract :
Ideally, decisions in technical organizations are made on the basis of science; in reality, these decisions are frequently subject to, and outweighed by, political or economic pressures. This phenomenon may be illuminated by examining project management from the perspective of systems theory. Discussed in this paper is the project management within the context of systems theory, using NASA\´s losses of the Mars Polar Lander and the Mars Climate Orbiter as examples. NASA uses the "faster, better, cheaper" (FBC) approach to project management. However, this approach embodies goals that are incommensurable: "faster" is a political goal; "better" is a scientific goal; and "cheaper" is an economic goal. NASA thus faces a rhetorical bind, in which its ostensible goal, "better," becomes subordinate to the goals of "faster" or "cheaper,".
Keywords :
aerospace engineering; project management; systems engineering; Mars Climate Orbiter; Mars Polar Lander; NASA; project management; systems theory; Binary codes; Bridges; Concrete; Environmental economics; Knowledge engineering; Mars; NASA; Professional communication; Project management; Space technology;
Conference_Titel :
Professional Communication Conference, 2003. IPCC 2003. Proceedings. IEEE International
Print_ISBN :
0-7803-7949-7
DOI :
10.1109/IPCC.2003.1245498