Title :
In pursuit of constructive criticism
Author :
Grove, Laurel K.
Abstract :
Practitioners and academics both are subject to and participate in frequent reviews, but these reviews often fail to provide useful results. This article illustrates problems with reviews, identifies common purposes for reviews, and presents recommendations for reviewers and review-seekers.
Keywords :
organisational aspects; product liability; professional communication; quality management; reviews; criticism; editorial review; evaluation pedagogy; peer review; product review; quality management; Collaborative work; Councils; Documentation; Extraterrestrial measurements; IEEE online publications; Proposals; Prototypes; Scheduling; Usability;
Journal_Title :
Professional Communication, IEEE Transactions on
DOI :
10.1109/TPC.2003.819644
