بررسي قرائتي منسوب به امير مومنان

A Study of the Reading Ascribed to Amar Al Ali (AS.)

A reading (qaraʹat) of Surat sl-ʹAfT, which is in contrast to the credible readings of the Holy Quian, is ascribed to Amʹr alMuʹrninln (AS.). Since it contains additions to the Surat aI-ʹAfT, its acceptance means omitting some parts of the Holy Quian. Examining the sanads of the two traditions that ascribe this reading to Imam ʹAil (AS.) indicates that these traditions are among the shiid traditions (those transmitted by a single narrator), that except for an unknown narrator, no one else has transmitted it. Abii IsI,aq Sablʹ is the only person who has related the tradition from that narrator. As for Abii IsI,aqʹs narrations, the biographers and tradition experts have raised objections to them because of their nonconformity to the samiiʹ (hearing), tahdItb (transmission of 1;JadIth), as well as his fraudulence. In addition, toward the end of his life, Abii IsI,aq suffered dementia and the aforementioned reading has also been transmitted in disagreement, to the extent that this disturbance and the disruption in its sanadinvalidate its acceptance.