نقد ديدگاه مخالفان عرض حديث بر قرآن

Criticism of the Views of the Opponents of Assessing Prophetic Traditions by the Qurun

There are certain measures for distinguishing between sound and unsound prophetic traditions. One of these methods, which is prescrihed by the Infalliblcs, is assessing prophetic traditions by Ihe holy Qur tun. Some Sunui schorlars express their dissatisfartion with this criterion claiming that the narrations in favour of the assessment of prophetic traditions by the Qur ian arc fabricated. The question that arises here is: what proofs do these scholars oller? what is wrong with (heir argumentʹ! The article explores the weaknesses in the argument of these scholars, stressing the necessity of referring to the Outun for assessing any suspected tradition. To this end, the article cites a number of narrations that confirm the necessity of referring 10 the Our ʹ an for the assessment of prophetic traditions, criucizcs the opponentsʹ views and refutes the claim that the narrations in favour of assessing prophetic traditions by the Qurian :HC Iabricatcd.