• DocumentCode
    1484590
  • Title

    Opinions on reviewing for technical journals [Commentary]

  • Author

    Greenstein, Larry J.

  • Volume
    48
  • Issue
    5
  • fYear
    2010
  • fDate
    5/1/2010 12:00:00 AM
  • Firstpage
    14
  • Lastpage
    16
  • Abstract
    A number of years ago, a young colleague asked me for advice on reviewing papers for technical journals. I replied with a letter laying out my accumulated wisdom on the subject and sent it off. In the years since, she has become an outstanding reviewer, and I naturally have attributed this to the letter I wrote her. Even so, I dusted the letter off recently to see if I have changed my mind in any important ways.
  • Keywords
    Communications Society; Reflection; Software tools;
  • fLanguage
    English
  • Journal_Title
    Communications Magazine, IEEE
  • Publisher
    ieee
  • ISSN
    0163-6804
  • Type

    jour

  • DOI
    10.1109/MCOM.2010.5458355
  • Filename
    5458355