Title :
Voting before discussing: computer voting as social communication
Author :
Whitworth, B. ; McQueen, R.J.
Author_Institution :
Dept. of Inf. Syst., Manukau Inst. of Technol., Auckland, New Zealand
Abstract :
Presents a case study on the use of an alternative method of computer support to that normally used, one that uses voting as a tool for social rather than rational choice. This voting-before-discussion (VBD) method is indicated in cases where agreement is an important group output, or where inter-personal conflict is creating problems in meetings. Given that participants are warned to avoid "groupthink", the VBD method seems to increase group unity, reduce inter-personal conflict and speed up decision making, while still allowing argument and analysis. The method is based on a three-process integrative theory of group interaction, which proposes that group cohesion arises primarily from normative influences rather than rational information exchange. If this model is correct, the VBD method may be just one of many new possible ways that computer support can be tailored to support group processes according to the nature of the group and the situation.
Keywords :
group decision support systems; negotiation support systems; social aspects of automation; agreement; argumentation; case study; computer voting; decision making; group cohesion; group interaction; group output; group participants; group unity; groupthink; integrative theory; inter-personal conflict; normative influence; social choice; social communication; voting before discussion; Collaborative software; Decision making; Decision support systems; Feedback; Management information systems; System software; Technology management; Voting;
Conference_Titel :
Systems Sciences, 1999. HICSS-32. Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Hawaii International Conference on
Conference_Location :
Maui, HI, USA
Print_ISBN :
0-7695-0001-3
DOI :
10.1109/HICSS.1999.772704