A performance comparison of elliptic curve scalar multiplication algorithms on smartphones

This work presents an evaluation of different software implementations of algorithms to compute the most demanding operation in cryptographic schemes based on Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC), the scalar multiplication. Five different methods were studied, including traditional and more sophisticated methods for elliptic curve cryptography defined over prime and binary fields. For evaluation, the key generation algorithm in ECC consisting on a single scalar multiplication was implemented on a P500h LG smarthphone, which includes an ARM processor running at 600MHz. Both execution time and memory usage was evaluated. It was found that in general, scalar multiplication runs 8 times faster for ECC defined over prime fields, being the NAF the best performer method. For ECC over binary fields, the best performer method was wNAF. The results presented in this work could help a designer to select the most appropriate method when implementing ECC-based cryptographic schemes such as encryption or digital signatures on mobile devices like smartphones, meeting implementation requirements in terms of execution time and memory usage.