Comments on "Throughput Analysis for Persistent CSMA Systems"

We present a brief and simple analysis of asynchronous (unslotted) 1-Persistent CSMA protocols in the worst-case star topology. The purpose is two-fold. First, we give a simple approach based on an embedded Markov chain at the beginning of subbusy periods that greatly simplifies the analysis. And second, using the above approach we give the correct analysis for 1-Persistent CSMA with collision detection, since the only available analysis of the present model [1] is in error.