پديد آورندگان :
بنويدي، فاطمه نويسنده , , سجودي ، فرزان نويسنده Sojoodi, F
كليدواژه :
آنتيگونه , تراژدي , تقدير تاريخي , سوفوكل , وجدان معذب
چكيده فارسي :
هگل در كتاب پديدارشناسي روح و در فلسفه هنرهاي زيبا خود، به مسيله تراژدي و چگونگي شكل‌گيري آن مي‌پردازد. اكثر پژوهندگان غربي مدعي هستند كه از زمان ارسطو تاكنون هيچ يك از انديشمندان اروپايي نتوانسته‌اند تراژدي و كمدي را آن طوركه هگل تبيين كرد مورد تحليل قرار دهند و تاكنون همواره نكته‌گيري‌هاي ژرفش، انديشمندان پس از او را به تامل واداشته است. نمونه تراژدي يوناني در نظر هگل، آنتيگونه سوفوكلس است. هگل در اثر معروف خود فلسفه هنرهاي زيبا به شرح و بسط تراژدي آنتيگونه مي‌پردازد. در طول تاريخ فلسفه در حوزه هاي مختلف رابطه هنر و فلسفه به وضوح مشاهده مي شود. اگرچه هگل متن كاملي در مورد زيبايي شناسي منتشر نكرد تا با علم منطق مقايسه كند، اين به اين معنا نيست، كه او هنر و زيبايي را در مرز نظام فلسفي خود پايين آورده، در واقع نظريه زيبايي شناسي هگل از قلب نظام فلسفي اش ناشي مي شود، و تنها مي تواند دور نمايي از آن سيستم شناخته شود. بر اين اساس ما در اين اوراق در پي آنيم كه بسته به بضاعت خويش، لحظه‌هاي بي‌زمان فراز و فرود تراژدي را، به تحرير كشيده و رخداد «وجدان معذب (آگاهي معذب)» هگلي را شرح داده، «برخورد تراژيك» را مصور كرده و دقيقه اي بازانديشي كنيم.
چكيده لاتين :
Hegel’s interpretation of Sophocles’ Antigone is surely one of the best we can find in literature or philosophy. In his book “Phenomenology of Spirit”, Hegel goes through insightful interpretations of Antigone and analyzes this work based on his own system of philosophy. Hegel is one of the few systematic philosophers who made a universal body of philosophy which is supposed to overwhelm all humanity’s questions and problems. Therefore in order to understand Antigone based on Hegel’s thoughts we should firstly get familiar with the basic ideas of Hegel. It seems that one of the main questions which can be regarded as the beginning point for Hegel is the relationship between God and human. In Christianity, God is in the shape of human and in Christian theology God is incarnated in a human being. The quality of God’s incarnation in Christ was irrational to young Hegel. He was thinking how it is possible that Infinite God can be incarnated in finite physical body of a human called Christ. This problem at the beginning is purely theoretical however later it becomes all his philosophy and inspires his absolute idealism. Theoretically speaking, the problem of God’s incarnation in Christ is that when we state it philosophically, it is the relation of the Infinite with the finite and when we state it politically it changes into the relation of the Government and an individual. In his book, Phenomenology of Spirit and also in his Aesthetics, Hegel presents inspiring ideas regarding the tragedy. Most western researchers believe that since Aristotle’s time, none of the European thinkers have been able to explain comedy and tragedy the way Hegel has done and his deep points of view have made his post-thinkers reflect on them. In Hegel’s view, Sophocles’ Antigone is a sample of Greek tragedy. In his famous work, Philosophy of Fine Arts, Hegel deals with the explanation of the tragedy of Antigone. Therefore, in this paper, considering our available means, the authors plan to portrait the rise and fall of the moments of tragedy and explain the event, “conscience malheureuse”, portrait “Tragic Clash” and rethink for moments. The gods, especially Zeus, are often dispensers of fate, sometimes superior to it, and sometimes constrained by it. Zeus and fate somehow determine events, but men have free will: fate exploits the character of men to maintain cosmic order. The Greeks are in harmony with nature; then a rift opens up between freedom and fate necessity; finally, Christianity begins the reign of providence. Hegel is also influenced by the Greek concept of fate, especially moria (‘allotted portion (especially of death), fate’, also personified s moira, ‘the Fates’), which approach in epic, tragedy and, especially in the guise of ananke (‘NECESSITY’), in pre-Socratic philosophers (especially Heraclitus). Thus, in this paper through the method of analytical-descriptive we intend to find out Hegel’s main philosophical problem and then we justify why Hegel had turned to Greek playwrights specifically Sophocles’ Antigone. At the end, we will discuss the idea of historical destination.
